Story image

Auditor-General's PGP report "too polite" says Labour's O'Connor

12 Mar 15

The Auditor-General's review of the government's $680 million primary growth partnership has come under scrutiny from the select committee which commissioned it, with Labour MP Damien O'Connor criticising it as "too polite".

The Office of the Auditor-General present the reported, which came out last month, to the primary production select committee today, and it gave O'Connnor, who has been critical of the scheme in the past, another chance to have a go.

The review into the Ministry of Primary Industries management of the programme, launched in 2009 and intended to lift investment in innovation and economic growth in the primary sector, was commissioned by the select committee, with a particular focus on the transparency of funding and the government agency's management of it.

The government and industry partners had committed some $680 million to the scheme, with the crown promising $322 million to 18 programmes, of which $129.5 million had been spent at Nov. 30. Labour has claimed conflicts of interest in the scheme , including among the investment advisory panel members, during the funding of projects.

Assistant Auditor-General Mike Scott told the select committee the review looked at how the MPI had managed funds allocation in the early stage and found there was "some looseness" in the early stages. O'Connor was more strident, saying "under resourced, chaotic, and arbitrary would be the accurate way of summarising your report".

On the issue of conflicts of interest, the review found the ministry did not have enough staff and resources during early funding round and the assessment process was loosely defined by cabinet and open to interpretation. The review found the investment advisory panels decisions were stated clearly, however the ministry did not "always clearly and comprehensively record the reasons for the IAP's decisions".

"PGP got off to a mixed start and initially encountered a number of challenges," Controller and Auditor-General Lyn Provost wrote in the review. "PGP partnerships are now generally working well and the management of them has improved in the past five years. More is required, in particular, to achieve clear, simple, and understandable public reporting on individual programmes and the PGP portfolio."

The Auditor-General said public reporting of the programme start "late and, to date, has not been suitable for a public audience because it is inconsistent and too technical". Improvements to public reporting would aid transparency and accountability, Provost said.

The review made three recommendations to MPI, including improving the initiative's investment advisory panel's documentation of its decision making process, ensuring that funded projects would have quantifiable long-term economic benefits and improving public reporting of the scheme and its progress.

DigiCert conquers Google's distrust of Symantec certs
“This could have been an extremely disruptive event to online commerce," comments DigiCert CEO John Merrill. 
Protecting organisations against internal fraud
Most companies tend to take a basic approach that focuses on numbers and compliance, without much room for grey areas or negotiation.
Telesmart to deliver Cloud Calling for Microsoft Teams
The integration will allow Telesmart’s Cloud Calling for Microsoft Teams to natively enable external voice connectivity from within Teams collaborative workflow environment.
Jade Software & Ambit take chatbots to next level of AI
“Conversation Agents present a huge opportunity to increase customer and employee engagement in a cost-effective manner."
52mil users affected by Google+’s second data breach
Google+ APIs will be shut down within the next 90 days, and the consumer platform will be disabled in April 2019 instead of August 2019 as originally planned.
GirlBoss wins 2018 YES Emerging Alumni of the Year Award
The people have spoken – GirlBoss CEO and founder Alexia Hilbertidou has been crowned this year’s Young Enterprise Scheme (YES) Emerging Alumni of the Year.
SingleSource scores R&D grant to explore digital identity over blockchain
Callaghan Innovation has awarded a $318,000 R&D grant to Auckland-based firm SingleSource, a company that applies risk scoring to digital identity.
IDC: Standalone VR headset shipments grow 428.6% in 3Q18
The VR headset market returned to growth in 3Q18 after four consecutive quarters of decline and now makes up 97% of the combined market.