Story image

Lawyers, WhaleOil and the changing media world

11 Oct 2014

Cameron Slater,the man behind the blog WhaleOil, his defamation case and the Dirty Politics saga, has sparked discussions about freedom of speech and what defines a journalist.

In the district court, Slater argued that he didn’t have to disclose his sources as he was protected as a journalist under the Evidence Act. When the court said he was not a journalist, he appealed to the High Court.

There, Justice Raynor Asher issued a ruling that said Slater was indeed a journalist. The decision was influenced by the fact that the WhaleOil site had a larger audience than some newspapers and was responsible for a number of news breaks, with genuine new information of interest across a variety of topics.

Justice Asher said, “The style of journalism may be criticised and can be dramatic and abusive, but the expression is vigorous and coherent, and there is no evidence provided to this Court of consistent inaccuracy or deceit (although there is evidence of consistent hyperbole).”

Newspaper Publishers’ Association (NPA) has said the fact that the High Court recognised Slater as a journalist is an interesting insight into how the media world is changing.

In New Zealand, freedom of the media is identified as an important aspect of democracy. In 2010, New Zealand ranked eighth on the Press Freedom Index for consistent strong, legal, public and media comment.

Section 68 of the Evidence Act 2006 enables journalists to protect the identity of their sources and is what Slater used in order to keep his sources to himself.

The freedom of the press favours journalists. There is a responsibility of journalists to observe good taste and decency, the maintenance of law and order and the privacy of the individual, but within that they are largely free to follow up stories and find evidence without the fear of facing a trial.

Better data management: Whose job is it?
An Experian executive’s practical advice on how to structure data-management roles within a modern business environment.
Platform9 and Intersect partner to bring unified cloud to A/NZ
“For Intersect, Platform9 represents the single most strategic solution to a set of challenges we see expanding across the board."
Meet the future of women in IT
Emily Sopers has just won Kordia’s first ever Women in Technology Scholarship, which was established to address gender imbalance in the information and communications technology (ICT) sector.
Web design programmers do an about face – again!
Google is aggressively pushing speed in the mobile environment as a critical ranking factor, and many eb design teams struggling to reach 80%+ speed scores on Google speed tests with gorgeous – but heavy - WordPress templates and themes.
Digital spending to hit US$1.2 trillion by 2022
A recent study by Zinnov shows that IoT spend reached US$201 billion in 2018 while outsourcing service providers generated $40 billion in revenue.
'Iwi Algorithm' can grow Aotearoa's mana
Ngāti Whātua Ōrākei innovation officer Te Aroha Grace says AI can help to combine the values from different cultures to help grow Aotearoa’s mana and brand – and AI is not just for commercial gain.
Dropbox brings in-country document hosting to A/NZ & Japan
Dropbox Business users in New Zealand, Australia, and Japan will be able to store their Dropbox files in-country, beginning in the second half of 2019.
Why 'right to repair' legislation could be a new lease on life for broken devices
“These companies are profiting at the expense of our environment and our pocketbooks as we become a throw-away society that discards over 6 million tonnes of electronics every year.”