Story image

Supreme Court upholds validity of Dotcom search warrants, Chief Justice dissents

24 Dec 14

The Supreme Court has ruled the search warrants executed in the high-profile arrest of internet entrepreneur Kim Dotcom were valid, although Chief Justice Sian Elias was a dissenting voice on the bench.

Justices John McGrath, William Young, Susan Glazebrook, Terence Arnold turned down Dotcom's appeal to have the warrants deemed invalid, saying they were not unreasonably vague and general, upholding a Court of Appeal ruling that their deficiencies weren't substantial enough to declare them void.

"We agree with the Court of Appeal that the appellants were reasonably able to understand what the warrants related to and that the police were adequately informed of what they should be looking for," the judges said in their judgment released today. "Any issues relating to matters such as the way the search of the computers was conducted or the handling of irrelevant material should be addressed through other processes."

Dotcom and his co-accused Finn Batato, Mathias Ortmann and Bram van der Kolk sought to have the warrants ruled invalid as they attempt to head off the US Federal government's bid to extradite them to the US, where they face charges of conspiracy to operate websites used to illegally distribute copyrighted material.

The majority agreed the warrants "could have been drafted rather more precisely," but were persuaded there was no significant prejudice in this case due to the explanations given by Detective Sergeant Stephen Humphries to Dotcom at the time of the search and that the internet entrepreneur understood the contents of the warrant.

"We consider that, viewed in isolation from the other alleged shortcomings, the deficiencies in the warrants in relation to the description of the offences did not result in a miscarriage of justice," the judges said.

Chief Justice Elias dissented from the majority and would have allowed the appeal, saying "the imprecision in the description of the offences exacerbated the overreach of the warrants which, especially in relation to the electronic devices authorised to be seized from domestic premises, was likely to include personal and irrelevant information."

She said the Court of Appeal was wrong to say the judge granting the warrant could rely on police to execute the warrants lawfully, as that was inconsistent with the legislative scheme.

The Chief Justice agreed with Justice Helen Winkelmann's High Court ruling that the warrants' defects didn't limit the authority conferred by law and couldn't be characterised as minor, technical breaches.

"A search warrant properly issued would not have authorised the seizure of irrelevant material, at least not without setting up conditions to ensure secure and expeditious sorting under the supervision of the court," the Chief Justice said. "Where, as here, a search warrant was overbroad and no protective conditions were imposed, the relevant miscarriage of justice is complete. If treated as valid, the warrant is authority for any trespass or breach of privacy entailed."

Dotcom and his co-accused were ordered to pay costs of $35,000 to the Crown.

Human value must be put back in marketing - report
“Digital is now so widely adopted that its novelty has worn off. In their attempt to declutter, people are being more selective about which products and services they incorporate into their daily lives."
Wine firm uses AR to tell its story right on the bottle
A Central Otago wine company is using augmented reality (AR) and a ‘digital first’ strategy to change the way it builds its brand and engages with customers.
DigiCert conquers Google's distrust of Symantec certs
“This could have been an extremely disruptive event to online commerce," comments DigiCert CEO John Merrill. 
Protecting organisations against internal fraud
Most companies tend to take a basic approach that focuses on numbers and compliance, without much room for grey areas or negotiation.
Telesmart to deliver Cloud Calling for Microsoft Teams
The integration will allow Telesmart’s Cloud Calling for Microsoft Teams to natively enable external voice connectivity from within Teams collaborative workflow environment.
Jade Software & Ambit take chatbots to next level of AI
“Conversation Agents present a huge opportunity to increase customer and employee engagement in a cost-effective manner."
52mil users affected by Google+’s second data breach
Google+ APIs will be shut down within the next 90 days, and the consumer platform will be disabled in April 2019 instead of August 2019 as originally planned.
GirlBoss wins 2018 YES Emerging Alumni of the Year Award
The people have spoken – GirlBoss CEO and founder Alexia Hilbertidou has been crowned this year’s Young Enterprise Scheme (YES) Emerging Alumni of the Year.